Authors for Peace
  • Home
  • The Idea
  • European Holiday! // Europäischer Feiertag!
  • Erinnerung braucht Intimität - Literatur in Südkorea
  • Verfassungsschutzbericht zur AfD (2019)
  • Manifest "Extinction Rebellion" auf Deutsch (Oktober 2019)
  • 2018
    • Contract for the Web 2018
    • Authoritarianism 2018
    • PEN America against Trump 2018
    • For our Future’s Sake - Brexit 2018
    • Gegen Nationalismus - 13-10.org 2018
    • Paradigm Shift Migration 2018
    • documented deaths of refugees 2018
    • Europäischer Feiertag im Literaturhaus Berlin 2018
    • Solidarität statt Heimat 2018
    • Cambridge Analytica 2018
    • Open Letter to Erdoğan 2018
    • Özdemirs Rede zur AfD 2018
    • Release Gui Minhai 2.2018
  • 2017
    • Europe 2017
    • Populism / Populismus 2017
    • Trump 2016 / 2017
    • CIA Surveillance tools 2017
    • Turkey / Türkei 2016 / 2017
    • #FreeDeniz 2017
    • „A Soul for Europe“ Konferenz 2017
    • Macron's Europe Speech 2017
    • An Open Letter to the Hannah Arendt Center at Bard College 2017
    • Bundestagswahl 2017
    • International Congress for Democracy and Freedom 2017
    • Political Murder Liu Xiaobo 2017
    • Anleitung Datensicherung / Guide data security 2017
    • Call for a European Public Holiday 2017
  • 2016
    • Refugees / Flüchtlinge 2016
    • China Press Freedom 2016
    • Pressefreiheit / Freedom of the Press 2016
    • Aleppo 2016
    • Brexit 2016
    • Friedenspreis an Emcke 2016
    • A poem by Ashraf Fayadh - World Poetry Day 2016
    • Flüchtlingspolitik: Österreichische Künstler protestieren 2016
    • Saudi Court overturns Ashraf Fayadh's death sentence 2016
    • wir machen das 2016
    • Worldwide Reading in support of Ashraf Fayadh 2016
    • Jews & Arabs Kiss 2016
  • 2015
    • Nein zu Pegida 2015
    • Charlie Hebdo 1/2015
    • A MESSAGE FROM PARIS by Ian McEwan / 2015
    • Aufruf für eine menschliche Flüchtlingspolitik (11.11.2015)
    • News Blog >
      • "hautbahnhof" 2015
      • Surveillance Blog
      • Snowden's Germany Files / Snowdens Deutschland-Dateien
      • David Miranda's unlawful detention
      • Russian laws choking free speech must be repealed now
      • The Day We Fight Back Against Mass Surveillance
      • Art Spiegelman on Surveillance
      • Stop Surveillance
      • Hacking Online Polls
      • Demo "Freiheit statt Angst"
  • "We Refugees" by Hannah Arendt
  • Free Liu Xiaobo 10/2014
  • Reset the Net 6/2014
  • Writers Against Mass Surveillance - Other Languages
    • Die Demokratie verteidigen im digitalen Zeitalter
    • Writers against mass surveillance
    • POUR UNE DÉFENSE DE LA DEMOCRATIE À L'ÈRE NUMÉRIQUE
    • En defensa de la democracia en la era digital
    • LOTTIAMO CONTRO I SISTEMI DI SORVEGLIANZA
    • Oproep tot democratie in het digitale tijdperk
    • Ett upprop för demokrati i den digitala tidsåldern
    • Til forsvar for demokratiet i en digital æra
    • Uppropet för demokrati i en digital tid
    • Í þágu lýðræðis á tölvuöld
    • فراخوان نویسندگان جهان: تحت نظر گرفتن سرقت &#
    • Dijital Çağda Bir Demokrasi Savunması
    • Η ΒΑΣΗ ΓΙΑ ΤΗ ΔΗΜΟΚΡΑΤΙΑ ΣΤΗΝ ΨΗΦΙΑΚΗ ΕΠΟΧΗ
    • Hentikan Pengintaian Masal
  • Worldwide Reading for Snowden
  • Snowden Interview
  • The NSA Archive
  • Snowden Interview by The Guardian
  • Snowdens Deutschland-Akten
  • NSA - "America, No You Can't" / September 2013
  • NSA - Brief an Bundeskanzlerin Merkel + Letter to Chancellor Merkel / August 2013
  • BETWEEN LINES – An Hour of Beauty // Zwischen Zeilen - Eine Stunde Schönheit
  • Release Li Bifeng / June 2013
  • 製造敵人是危險的 ——我們呼籲中國政府釋放李必豐 簽名發起人:艾未&
  • One Billion Rising February 2013
  • Reading for Pussy Riot December 2012
  • Liu Xiabo: I Have No Enemies - December 2012
  • Gangnam Style for Ai Weiwei - November 2012
  • APPEL DE STRASBOURG / STRASBOURG APPEAL / STRASSBURGER APPELL - October 2012
  • Free our Sisters - Pussy Riot September 2012
  • Aufruf Shahin Najafi - Juni 2012
  • Reading against Assad, for democracy in Syria - April 2012
  • Lesung gegen Assad, für Demokratie in Syrien - April 2012
  • نداء من سمر يزبك، كاتبة سورية، إلى جميع الك
  • Petition - Release Liu Xiaobo December 2012
  • Liu Xiabo we stand with you - March 2012
  • Liu Xiabo March 2012 Worldwide Reading
  • Liu Xiabo März 2012 Weltweite Lesung
  • Appeal Liu Xiaobo 2011
    • Signatories
  • Aufruf Liu Xiaobo 2011
    • Unterzeichner
    • Herta Müller zu Liu Xiaobo
  • 9/11 – Ten Years On
  • 9/11 - Zehn Jahre später
  • International Women’s Day 2011
  • Peace Day Event 2010
    • The Authors
    • Reading Schedule
  • Important Speeches - Wichtige Reden
    • Joachim Gauck: Einbürgerungsfeier anlässlich 65 Jahre Grundgesetz, 22. Mai 2014
    • Steinmeier: "Remembering the Holocaust: Fighting Antisemitism" (January 2020)
  • The Life You Can Save - Always
  • Contact
21.7.2018

We need a paradigm shift in the way we think about migration

More than 500 academics including Thomas Piketty call for a science-based approach to policies on immigration and the creation on an International Panel on Migration and Asylum



Like climate change, migration is a global issue that needs to be addressed both locally and internationally. The regulation of population movements has long been a pitfall of international cooperation. The European asylum crisis of 2015 revealed that, even in highly integrated and cooperative contexts such as the EU, unpreparedness, political confusion and misinformation generate inadequate and humanly costly policy responses. At the global level, from the 1990 convention on migrant workers’ rights to the currently discussed “global compacts”, attempts to coordinate policies and foster global governance fell short of providing innovative and impactful solutions.

The recent inflow of Syrian asylum seekers in Europe forced upon EU leaders and citizens a brutal awareness regarding the global refugee crisis that is mostly unfolding in the global south. This particular refugee inflow resonates with broader discussions on immigration, integration and diversity in European societies fragilised by the 2008 economic crisis. The current European crisis is made of the confusion of short- and long-term policy issues, of asylum and migration regulation, of debates around rights, politics and economics, which cannot be solely addressed at the national level.

Beyond Europe, the emergence or entrenchment of political crises around migration and asylum issues calls for an urgent reaction of all stakeholders. Scientists, civil society organisations, activists, concerned citizens and policymakers must join forces to bring about a better understanding of migration, both forced and voluntary, of its determinants and consequences for host societies and countries of origin. By doing so, we will provide grounds for evidence-based policymaking and sound practices beyond ideological constructions and discourses that obfuscate debates in the media and political arena today.

This call for a change of approach has become urgent.

• Since the 1990s, attempts by the UN or regional organisations such as the EU to regulate migration and asylum have failed (The 1990 convention, the Dublin agreements in Europe, up to the global compacts) and collapsed when confronted by the trial of either refugee arrivals (Iraq, Syria, South Sudan, Burma) or political crises around migrants’ incorporation and diversity.

The policy options adopted by OECD countries in the past decade – building walls, externalising control at high political and financial costs – will neither prevent people leaving their country, nor will it impact the determinants of migration in the long run as often repeated by scientists and shown by recent experiences.

The lack of understanding of the impact of migration in host and receiving societies generates enduring mismanagement. Fearmongering discourses infuse policy agendas and ignores scientific knowledge. Although scientific controversies on migration and asylum do exist, some well-established facts remain unheard and unused in policymaking:

• Migration mostly occurs within regions and not between continents. Migrants are mostly located in the global south, especially refugees.

• 246 million migrants only represent 3.4% of the world’s population, far less than in the 19th century.

• Visa restrictions increase the settlement of immigrants already present in a host country: migrant workers stay instead of moving back and forth across countries. The absence of visa opportunities for asylum seekers in countries of origin and transit also increases criminal practices and smuggling.

• Border closure not only restricts mobility but also exchanges and transfers of funds, knowhowand ideas across borders.

• Rapid access to housing, education as well as the formal labour market increases the quality of incorporation of migrants and asylum seekers in host societies, further reducing inequalities and disenfranchisement.

• The impact of migration on population trends is short-lived as fertility behaviours rapidly catch up with demographic patterns in host countries.

• Financing development can increase emigration in poor countries, making the migration-development relations much more complex than what current policies present as grounds for action. The effect of immigrant inflows on labour market outcomes and national growth is neutral or positive overall, depending upon economic conditions and dynamics, upon workers’ mobility and labour market regulations.

In understanding the impact of immigration, analyses that are both context-specific and connected to global dynamics are crucial to determine the effects of migration. Recent concern has been formulated about the lack or unreliable quality of migration data. Beyond data, we argue that robustness and clarity in the analytical premises of policymaking is the key to sound and efficient regulation of population movement. One-size-fits-all and ideology-based policies do not work.

We therefore urge the ending of the short-term and inadequate political solutions that brought us to political and humanitarian crises. We ask for a radical change of paradigm in dealing with migration and asylum, based on a rational, realistic, scientifically informed and humanist approach. We thus call for an emergency meeting of scientists and experts to inform policymaking, and for the creation of an International Panel on Migration and Asylum.

Virginie Guiraudon CNRS director of research, Sciences Po, Paris, Andrew Geddes Director, Migration Policy Centre, European University Institute, Italy, Steven Vertovec Director, Max Planck Institute, Germany, Jean Jouzel Founding member of the International Panel on Climate Change, Thomas Piketty Co-director, World Inequality Database, Paris and more than 500 others. Full list of signatories at www.iepam.eu/posts/list-of-signatures


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.